Story #033
Living the Questions: My Spiritual Story Begins
Max J Miller
It happened again. Yesterday a new acquaintance asked me, “Are you religious?”
I hear variations of this question frequently:
– Do you believe in God?
– Are you a Christian?
– Do you believe in the Bible?
I used to think my language and demeanor elicited these questions. If you’ve read my weekly missives for a month or more, you know I tend to quote Jesus frequently, along with Lao Tsu, the Buddha, and other sages. (I do have a degree in Religious Studies.)
However, I’m beginning to suspect these questions have less to do with me and more to do with stirrings in the modern human psyche. According to current studies, the fastest-growing category of religious identification is “none.” We speak of our culture as rational, secular, and even materialistic. However, there are signs of an explosion of interest in spiritual matters—just take a glance at bestseller lists.
By now, my regular readers can guess how I might answer these questions about my spiritual inclinations: I share a story. Each time, I share a variation of what I call “my journey of faith,” which follows the classic story arc of your typical rom-com.
In the first act of a rom-com, the boy sees the girl from a distance but struggles to find a safe way to approach her. Then, often by accident, he meets the girl, and courtship ensues (with varying degrees of difficulty). Then something happens, and the couple part ways unhappily (boy loses girl). Finally, after some epiphany (an aha moment usually on the boy’s part), the couple joyously reconciles and lives happily ever after.
Kurt Vonnegut famously created eight “story shapes” to map the protagonist’s journey through seasons of good and bad fortune. “Boy Meets Girl” is one of those classic shapes. Below, I’ve kept Vonnegut’s Boy Meets Girl story shape, but changed the label to “Boy Meets God.”
Over the next two weeks, I’ll share my faith journey following the sequence in the Story Shape above.
Please understand, I’m not sharing this with any evangelistic agenda—I don’t have one. However, an authentic expression of one’s spiritual journey deserves an essential place in our wisdom legacy, whatever form that takes. I hope I may inspire you to reflect and, in some way, document your journey—if not for your descendants, for yourself.
GLIMPSES FROM A DISTANCE
So here’s my story’s glimpse-from-a-distance phase. Before my parents divorced when I was nine, we belonged to the church-of-the-month club. We attended a Protestant church within a few blocks of wherever we lived. I was baptized in a Presbyterian Church (as an infant), but we also attended Congregational and Methodist parishes.
We attended sporadically at best, and sometimes, my parents sent us to Sunday School even when we weren’t going to worship services. I received my own Bible when I was confirmed, but I don’t remember reading it outside of church and Sunday school.
My folks each remarried within fifteen months of their divorce. My new (step) dad and brother were Catholic. And because he married a divorced woman, my new dad was kicked out of his Church. I felt sad for him, but I found it all fascinating.
My father married the daughter of a Lutheran minister. Three of her siblings were Lutheran ministers, and one of her other siblings married a Lutheran minister. My new extended family on my father’s side took religion very seriously. It was part of their daily lives and conversations.
At family gatherings, the Lutherans engaged in philosophical and theological (and occasionally political) discussions. Amazingly, the minister brothers disagreed about many subjects, and occasionally their discussions heated up. Eventually, I joined some of these dialogues and asked questions.
A CLOSER LOOK
As a preteen, I started thinking more about God and spiritual matters. I occasionally attended Catholic mass with my brother. I attended dozens of Bar Mitzvahs and Bat Mitzvahs of my Jewish friends. My stepmother’s mother (the wife and mother of all those Lutheran ministers) gave me a “study Bible” for Christmas, and I started to read it occasionally.
According to my mother, the babysitter who watched over my siblings and me while my parents honeymooned and vacationed was a “real holy roller.” I knew something was up when she tried to get me to memorize some Bible verses.
Two events brought spiritual matters from the background of life into the foreground.
One of my freshman homeroom classmates committed suicide. We weren’t close friends, but the week before he died, I had been helping him at the school pool to complete his swimming merit badge for the Boy Scouts. I was devastated by the news. I cried and mourned for my classmate more than for my dear Grandma, just a couple of years before. It’s the first time I recall giving serious thought to what happens to us after we die.
Shortly after he died, my “holy roller” babysitter gave my mother two tickets to take me to a magic show. I loved magic, so I was eager to go. My mother was suspicious, however, since the tickets came from this woman who was not shy about “sharing the love of Jesus” with everyone and anyone.
The magician was André Kole, who had designed illusions for David Copperfield and other prominent magicians. His show was dazzling and I was enthralled.
At the end of his final spectacular illusion, in which he transported a woman from a box on one side of the stage to another, we gleefully joined the crowd in a standing ovation.
As Mr. Kole set up his encore, he told us he would use the final illusion to illustrate his most remarkable spiritual discovery and let us step out if we preferred. We stayed put, but I sensed my mother getting uneasy.
The last illusion was astonishing, but his “spiritual discovery” came right out of a Billy Graham crusade sermon, complete with an altar call to “come forward and receive Jesus as your personal savior.”
Well, I started to get out of my seat at Mr. Kole’s invitation, and my mother quickly and firmly grabbed my arm and pulled me back into my seat. “We aren’t that type of Christian,” she whispered urgently. She had made a similar remark about our evangelistic babysitter, but I wasn’t clear about what type of Christian my mother considered us to be.
“What kind of Christian am I?” I wondered. Various flavors of religious life surrounded me, and I even had some religious “experts” in the family. Still, I had more questions than answers.
According to Vonnegut’s “Boy Meets Girl” story shape, what I’ve shared in my faith journey hasn’t even reached the “first kiss” milestone. If you’ll indulge me, I’ll share the rest of the journey over the next two weeks. Parts of my story resemble a rollercoaster more than the simple shape above.
Truth is, I still have more questions than answers, but if I’ve learned anything, it’s this: life is more about the journey than the destination. In his Letters to A Young Artist, Rainer Maria Rilke wisely advises, “Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer.”
Shine,
Subscribe to the Newsletter
Join Max J Miller Blog and receive new online content directly in your inbox.
Recommended for Your Journey
Discover more inspiring reads that support your journey toward growth, purpose, and emotional well-being.